Case study · Finance and accounting

Commission reconciliation for brokers

Company-reported case study

Actigy BPO operated a reconciliation desk for Harborline Brokers, a commercial insurance broker working with 28 carriers. Over five months, the reported close cycle moved from nine business days to four business days.

Actigy BPO confirms the engagement and supporting records. Results apply to the stated scope and measurement windows.

Close cycle

Result

4 business days

Baseline: 9 business days

Window: 5 months

Supporting record: ERP report

Commission disputes

Result

0.4 / month

Baseline: 3.4 / month

Window: 5 months

Supporting record: Issue tracker

Unallocated cash

Result

$6k

Baseline: $84k

Window: 5 months

Supporting record: ERP report

Client profile

Harborline Brokers, a US commercial insurance brokerage with 140 staff.

Challenge and scope

Carrier statements arrive in different formats and cause three to four commission disputes in a typical month. Unallocated cash makes the close harder to complete.

Carrier statements can contain premium changes, reversals, or commissions paid against a policy reference different from the broker’s record. If staff allocate cash without tying a line back to the policy activity, the amount can disappear from an open-items list while the basis for the allocation stays unclear.

Delivery workflow

Match 2,400 statements and about $1.2 million in monthly commission to receipts and policy records. Investigate unmatched entries and send commission disputes to the broker when contract interpretation is needed.

Match the carrier statement to the policy, producer or agency record, and receipt in Applied Epic using the available references. Mark timing differences, cancellations, offsets, and discrepancies in the amount owed as separate items. Prepare an exception candidate with the underlying statement line and policy activity intact.

The reconciliation lead can produce a carrier schedule with cleared cash and aging items before the close deadline. Route differences that depend on a negotiated rate or carrier agreement to the broker’s owner. Track ongoing disputes through the carrier response and mark the final allocation with the approval reference.

Delivery team

Poland, about 5 FTE. 1 finance lead, 2 commission analysts and 2 reconciliation associates.

Systems and tools

Applied Epic, carrier portals.

Client decision rights

The broker owns commission schedules, carrier contracts, and final approval.

Early milestone

At week 5, the close takes seven business days.

Outcomes

Company-reported results, with the baseline, measurement window and supporting record described for each measure.

Reported results: Commission reconciliation for brokers
MeasureBaselineResultWindowSupporting record
Close cycle9 business days4 business days5 monthsERP report
Commission disputes3.4 / month0.4 / month5 monthsIssue tracker
Unallocated cash$84k$6k5 monthsERP report

Interpreting the results

The drop in unallocated cash from $84,000 to $6,000 can affect the close only if the allocation was supported. Compare that balance on the same close date with statement completeness and dispute age. Flag cash that moved to a temporary account and carry the source reference into the following close.

Recommendations for new clients

For brokers with a multi-carrier close, test the workflow on high-volume carriers first. Measure unallocated cash at the same close cutoff before and during the pilot.

Use one carrier with consistent statement files and one with a history of reversals or adjustments. Provide the broker’s policy and commission references and its dispute escalation path. Review whether the close schedule shows what is paid, what is unresolved, and what needs a contract interpretation before expanding to more carriers.

Scope this workflow for your operation

Use the documented workflow, client-held decisions and operational checks to outline a pilot for your own workload.